For home cooks comparing gotham steel air fryer reviews, this Gotham Steel Crisper Tray offers an oven-based way to air fry, roast, reheat, and bake on a compact two-piece set.
Its raised mesh basket and catch pan may suit smaller batches, provided the round footprint fits your oven and cooking routine.
Gotham Crisper Tray Review Summary
The quick verdict

13,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsGotham Steel Crisper Tray
A practical fit for cooks who want to crisp smaller portions in an oven or convection setting without adding a standalone air fryer.
- Two-piece set with an elevated mesh basket and solid catch tray.
- Round copper-colored set measuring 13.12 inches across.
- Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating.
- Designed for air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating in an oven, convection oven, or compatible air-fry mode.
Pros
- Raised mesh construction allows hot air to reach food from more sides than a flat pan alone.
- The solid pan beneath the basket catches drips and loose crumbs during cooking.
Consider before buying
- The 13.12-inch round shape may limit batch size or conflict with other items on a crowded oven rack.
- The set depends on an oven or convection cooking setup; it is not a standalone countertop air fryer.
Read the full review summary
The set pairs an elevated mesh basket with a solid round tray, letting heat circulate around food while the lower pan catches drips and crumbs.
Its aluminum core, titanium and ceramic nonstick coating, dishwasher-safe construction, and stated freedom from PTHE, PFOA, and PFOS make it a feature-rich alternative to dedicating counter space to a separate appliance.
Its main appeal is flexibility in a standard oven, convection oven, or oven air-fry mode.
The 13.12-inch round size is compact relative to a full sheet pan, but capacity will depend on the food and oven layout; measure the usable rack space and consider whether your usual portions can sit in a single layer.
The buying factors
Gotham Crisper Tray Scorecard
Editorial scores reflect listed features and buyer fit; they are not laboratory measurements or customer ratings.
Cooking versatility
The basket and pan are intended for air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating in oven-based cooking modes.
Airflow design
The raised mesh basket exposes food to circulating hot air, while the pan beneath catches drips.
Oven fit flexibility
The round 13.12-inch set is described for standard racks and some convection ovens, though fit should be checked against the buyer’s own oven.
Cleanup convenience
The coated basket and tray are dishwasher safe, and the lower pan helps contain crumbs and grease.
Material and coating detail
The construction specifies an aluminum core and titanium and ceramic nonstick coating, with several named substances excluded.
Portion flexibility
A compact round surface is useful for modest batches, but the description does not establish usable cooking capacity for particular foods or servings.
Key Features and Specifications of Gotham Crisper Tray
- Two-piece set with an elevated mesh basket and solid catch tray.
- Round copper-colored set measuring 13.12 inches across.
- Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating.
- Designed for air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating in an oven, convection oven, or compatible air-fry mode.
- Dishwasher-safe construction and a lower tray to catch grease and crumbs.
- The materials are described as free of PTHE, PFOA, and PFOS.
Pros and Cons of Gotham Crisper Tray
Pros
- Raised mesh construction allows hot air to reach food from more sides than a flat pan alone.
- The solid pan beneath the basket catches drips and loose crumbs during cooking.
- Its stated uses span air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating.
- The coated surfaces are dishwasher safe, which can simplify routine cleanup.
Consider before buying
- The 13.12-inch round shape may limit batch size or conflict with other items on a crowded oven rack.
- The set depends on an oven or convection cooking setup; it is not a standalone countertop air fryer.
- The supplied description gives no cooking capacity by servings, so buyers should judge usable space against the foods they prepare.
Who Should Buy Gotham Crisper Tray?
Good fit
Consider this tray if you already cook with an oven or convection setting and want a dedicated raised basket for smaller portions.
The mesh-over-pan arrangement is especially practical for foods that release crumbs or drippings, since the lower tray can catch them during cooking.
It may also suit a kitchen where counter space is limited and a separate appliance would be inconvenient.
Before buying, measure your rack and check that the round footprint leaves enough room for the food and any other cookware you use at the same time.
Who should skip it
Skip it if your routine depends on cooking large batches at once or you need a self-contained countertop appliance. The compact round format and oven-based design may not match those needs.
If you need a particular serving capacity, confirm that the cooking surface can hold your usual portions in a single layer before choosing it.
How the Gotham Crisper Tray Fits Oven Cooking
Raised basket and crisping approach
The mesh basket sits above a solid tray, creating space beneath the food while leaving its sides exposed to circulating oven air.
That layout is intended to support crisping without immersing food in oil, although the result will depend on the food, portion size, and oven settings.
A useful catch pan
The lower tray gives grease and crumbs a place to collect instead of falling directly onto the oven rack or floor.
It also makes the set more than a mesh rack alone, but the pan still needs room to slide onto the rack and be handled with an oven mitt.
Size and kitchen fit
At 13.12 inches across, the round shape is positioned for standard oven racks and some smaller convection ovens.
A measurement of the oven’s usable rack area is the simplest way to assess compatibility; also account for rack edges and neighboring cookware.
Coating and care
The aluminum-core construction uses a titanium and ceramic nonstick coating, and both pieces are described as dishwasher safe.
That combination may make release and cleanup easier, while buyers who prefer hand washing or have specific coating-care routines should follow the product’s care guidance.
Alternatives to Gotham Crisper Tray
Grill Baskets alternative

700+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsCave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket
Choose the Gotham Steel set for oven-based air frying and a catch tray underneath; consider the Cave Tools basket if your priority is cooking smaller foods directly on an outdoor grill.
- The Cave Tools basket is a rectangular stainless steel grill basket for foods such as vegetables, fruit, shrimp, fish, and meat.
- It has a curved handle, is dishwasher safe, and is described for use over a grill.
- The Gotham Steel set is designed for oven and convection cooking, with a round mesh basket above a catch tray.
Grill Baskets alternative

1,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsKona Extra Large Grill Basket
The Gotham Steel design better matches oven use and drip collection, while the Kona is the more relevant choice for larger servings of vegetables on an outdoor grill.
- The Kona is a 14-by-13-by-4-inch outdoor grilling basket with extra-large capacity for vegetables, a nonstick coating, and construction intended for high temperatures.
- The Gotham Steel tray is a 13.12-inch round oven basket and pan set for compact oven-based cooking.
Is Gotham Crisper Tray Worth It?
The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray is worth considering if you want a compact oven accessory that combines an elevated mesh basket with a catch pan.
Its dishwasher-safe coating, multipurpose oven design, and rounded footprint make it a practical fit for smaller batches and kitchens that already rely on an oven or convection setting.
The main tradeoff is capacity: a 13.12-inch round surface may not suit larger meals or crowded racks. Measure your oven and compare the usable basket area with your usual portions before buying.
Your review at a glance

13,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsGotham Steel Crisper Tray
A practical fit for cooks who want to crisp smaller portions in an oven or convection setting without adding a standalone air fryer.
- Two-piece set with an elevated mesh basket and solid catch tray.
- Round copper-colored set measuring 13.12 inches across.
- Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating.
- Designed for air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating in an oven, convection oven, or compatible air-fry mode.